Case closed on "The Lost Files of Sherlock Holmes: The Case of the Serrated Scalpel"!

So much detail in these scenes...

After finding the culprits behind the murder of Sarah Carroway in The Lost Files of Sherlock Holmes: The Case of the Serrated Scalpel, I was led to a pawn shop. It didn't take long for the owner to spill the beans. This led me to the offices of a couple of private investigators who also got entangled in the Carroway case. 

Is it African or Indian?

Too bad for them, though, as I discovered after a visit to the zoo trying to find one of them, and tracking the other one down at a subway station. Suffice to say the case got an even darker edge and started to cost innocent lives. And if that wasn't enough, suddenly we also got a suicide on our hands! Filled with remorse, the person responsible for all the trouble in this story decided to take his own life after we discovered the truth. 

Plenty of drama in this game...

Then it took quite some searching and putting a couple of details together to finally discover where the missing Anna Carroway was. I must admit I was kinda stuck there at first, having exhausted all options, missing the next lead because I couldn't immediately connect the dots. But everything turned out alright in the end.

Took me long enough to find this place...

As far as I can tell, The Lost Files of Sherlock Holmes: The Case of the Serrated Scalpel isn't currently available for purchase anywhere, though you CAN vote to put it on GOG!

My next playthrough will most likely be of a recent game again, about some guy who keeps getting killed over and over again or something...

The plot thickens in "The Lost Files of Sherlock Holmes: The Case of the Serrated Scalpel"

This is where I learned the word "taxidermist"...

After following one lead after another, I discovered the identity of the possible murderer of Sarah Carroway in Covent Garden. It took me some time beating several patrons of the Moongate Pub, as well as the bartender, at darts. The name led me to yet another series of London locations where I presumably found the murder weapon as well: the famed serrated scalpel!

Skipper's goin' down!

Using the unbeatable nose of Toby, Holmes's favorite search dog, we found our way to the docks where the murderer was doing some business with a yet to identified stranger. We caught the murderer, but the stranger vamoosed in the struggle. Locked up in jail, the murderer isn't exactly cooperating, so we need some more dirt on him to make him talk.

Run, Sherlock, run!

Following some other leads I had abandoned for a while, I finally learned the name of that rugby player. Talking to him led me to yet another handful of locations and now in search of the victim's sister, Anna. After three hours of gameplay, it seems I have finally discovered the true motive behind the killing, and what is actually at stake here.

Once again succeeded in making a grown man cry...

After exhausting all other leads, I've returned to jail to confront the killer and indeed, he gives us another name, the identity of the second man at the docks. Could this lead us to the final chapter in this story? The answers seem to lie in a small pawn shop. Let's go find out!

I just knew someone posh was involved...

As far as I can tell, The Lost Files of Sherlock Holmes: The Case of the Serrated Scalpel isn't currently available for purchase anywhere, though you CAN vote to put it on GOG!

"Agatha Christie - Death on the Nile", my Adventure Game Hotspot review!

Read my full review on Adventure Game Hotspot!

Excerpt: "I’m terribly ashamed to admit it, but I’ve never read the original Death on the Nile novel. I will get around to it someday, but in the meantime I was very happy to play through this interactive and embellished version of the story. For those who have read it or seen the various movie adaptations, the addition of Jane should add some much-needed novelty, and the two storylines of Jane and Poirot intertwine masterfully and even lead to an epilogue I didn’t see coming but made perfect sense. There seems to be a lot more to do here than on the Orient Express – perhaps even a bit too much that doesn’t really seem relevant to the story. And yet I was captivated by the setting and scenery, and really liked searching around for clues and elusive collectibles, as well as questioning people and trying to figure out their secrets. I’m very much a fan of these Poirot games, so I hope that if there’s another, Microids remembers that solving a murder with one of literary fiction’s greatest detectives is interesting enough without a boatful of diversions."

Classic time: "The Lost Files of Sherlock Holmes: The Case of the Serrated Scalpel"

Replay!

After playing Casebook 1899: The Leipzig Murders, I was in the mood for some more sleuthing. Coincidence has it that in my list of classic playthroughs I had just come to an old friend from my youth again: The Lost Files of Sherlock Holmes: The Case of the Serrated Scalpel by Mythos Software. As is the case with many classic adventure games, I lost count of the amount of times I've played through this game. It's been a while now, so let's see how much of it I still remember during this replay!

Severe case of sciophobia...

London, 1888. A woman is attacked and killed in an alley behind the Regency Theatre. Inspector Lestrade requests Holmes's presence and so, accompanied by Dr. Watson, I make my way there. This point 'n click adventure uses a verb interface. Every piece of dialogue is recorded by Watson and can be read again under the Journal button. There are lots of hotspots and each one has an elaborate description. The game hails from a time when there weren't any voice-overs, though the cutscenes ARE voiced.

The scene of the crime...

After an hour of gaming, I've searched the crime scene and the victim's residence, conducted some chemical experiments on some pieces of evidence, sent Wiggins on an errand, and found a couple of leads which led me to several locations across London. Each time you think you're getting close, a new clue pops up taking you even deeper into the case.

This travel map taught me my way around London...

So far, only one thing bothered me a bit and that was an artificial lenghtening of the game by having you bump into some bureaucracy, forcing you into some back and forth between NPC's to get past some red tape before you can actually continue your investigation. All that stuff had nothing to do with the murder, but in hindsight perhaps it's an authentic and realistic obstacle to run into. It isn't fun, though.

Ugh... Sports...

My search led me to the Kensington rugby field. I found some evidence leading to one of the players, but the coach won't let me come near him unless I can tell him a name. I haven't found a name yet, though, but thankfully I've just found another lead that might prove fruitful in this regard. Back to late 19th century London it is! 

As far as I can tell, The Lost Files of Sherlock Holmes: The Case of the Serrated Scalpel isn't currently available for purchase anywhere, though you CAN vote to put it on GOG!

I finished "Casebook 1899: The Leipzig Murders", but it took some trial and error...

A lovely, deserted city...

Casebook 1899: The Leipzig Murders consists of four cases, and for each one the difficulty level is raised. It's masterfully done, but I must say it's not a good feeling when a puzzle totally stumps you, even AFTER you brute-forced the solution by trying every possible combination.

Reminds me of my to-read pile...

I greatly enjoyed the third case and I was glad to see I could really accuse the person I already had my sights on for a while. But then the final case came along, which turned everything upside down and I must admit, I was completely lost.

Madame Sophia?

There were two puzzles I couldn't figure out. With the first, the locker room puzzle, I had no idea where to even start. I missed seeing the pattern, but once you realize what it's so supposed to be, you can complete the puzzle in a jiffy. The second was the puppet puzzle, of which I still don't know how you are supposed to figure it out. It's basically a code, but not only is there a specific order to clicking on the puppets when they're on the shelf, it seems there's also a specific order to placing them there in the first place! I had a feeling it had something to do with Shakespeare, but for the life of me I couldn't figure it out -- and still can't!

No master of puppets, me...

But other than that, and the rather deus-ex-machina demise of the villain, I totally enjoyed this game to no end. The investigations, the deductions, it's all great sleuthing material that kept me fully entertained for a solid 8 hours, and I hope we might get some more murder games from Homo Narrans Studio in the future!

This game did spark the desire for some more detective work, so for my next playthrough (which will be a replay for me, in fact) I'll be travelling back in time from Leipzig in 1899, to London in 1888...

You can find Casebook 1899: The Leipzig Murders on Steam!

Busy investigating the third death in "Casebook 1899: The Leipzig Murders"

Posh...

The second case in Casebook 1899: The Leipzig Murders took me an hour and a half. I had actually found the solution, but I thought I was still missing something since one piece of evidence on the deduction board wasn't connected to the others. So I did another round of questioning people, but there were no missed dialogue options. So I just went for it, and it looked like I got it right.

The puzzle of a thousand clicks...

It was a far more interesting case than the first one, with lots more character interactions and even some mini-games. One involved the typical convoluted fuse box which was trickier than it looked. And yes, you can skip it, but where's the feeling of accomplishment in that? Another one was a far simpler lockpicking simulator which offered no challenge at all. You just had to correctly line up the tumblers. But it was fun for variety's sake.

Not much skill involved here...

The third case really has me running around. I've played The Leipzig Murders for 4,5 hours in total now, but I think it'll be a while before I solve this particular murder. I have an intuitive feeling of who the real murderer is, but I'm still lacking the evidence to put that person up on the deduction board. Thankfully I just unlocked a new area, so I'm hoping to finally crack it!

One more unemployed cleaning lady...

You can find Casebook 1899: The Leipzig Murders on Steam!

New game: "Casebook 1899: The Leipzig Murders"

New game!

When I played the demo of Casebook 1899: The Leipzig Murders back in 2022, immediately I knew I wanted to back its Kickstarter. Being a longtime fan of Sherlock Holmes, I was very interested in another deduction-based adventure in a traditional point 'n click style, only this time featuring a German police inspector in an original story by Gregor Müller of Homo Narrans Studio. And here were are, with the game finally released!

A first case to solve!

The first chapter is the demo I had already played, but since that was several years ago it felt like the first time again. This time, I could enjoy voice-overs too! Yes, they are German only, and not being very fluent I'm glad there are English subtitles, but it does give The Leipzig Murders its authenticity. Not every line is spoken, though. The conversations and cutscenes are, but Joseph Kreiser's comments on whatever you click on only feature a hum, mumble or the occasional "Interessant..." though strangely enough even when it concerns - in my humble opinion - far from interesting hotspots.

Wir sind in Deutschland, mein Liebchen!

But it's the investigation part that matters. I love how you can discover evidence but then have to decide for your own what really happened. It really takes a sharp mind to find the truth, since at first glance every possibility seems to be genuine.

Accident or homicide, that's the question...

I've solved the first case in slightly less than hour - and I've already started to talk German to my wife... - but I probably did remember most of it from the demo. Now it is immediately on to der Bahnhoff for the second of the four cases in this game. Hopefully this one will have some more meat on its bones.

Choo-choo!

You can find Casebook 1899: The Leipzig Murders on Steam!